To court storm or not to court storm?

Sports editors Hunter Mitchell and Luke White debate the common basketball sight

Hunter Mitchell and Luke White • February 29, 2024

Fans during Texas A&M’s game against Tennessee on Saturday, Feb. 10, 2024, at Reed Arena. (Ishika Samant/The Battalion)

Court storming isn’t going anywhere – Hunter Mitchell

Indiana’s Christian Watford’s 3-point shot to beat No. 1 Kentucky in 2011. Marquette over No. 1 Villanova in 2017. Northwestern’s win over Michigan in 2017, a team who had never made the NCAA tournament in its history up until that ticket-sealing victory.

Besides all being etched as some of the most well-known moments in college basketball history, what do all of these games have in common?

They were all followed by a court storm.

Synonymous with upset buzzer-beaters, wins over rivals and just about any victory of major relevance, court storming has been a tradition as old as hardwood and hoops itself. But now, there are those who would like to rid the game of it entirely.

“Fans don’t belong on the court,” ESPN Basketball Analyst Jay Bilas said on “Get Up.” “ … The NCAA doesn’t want it to stop and by the NCAA, I mean the member institutions. They like the visual, they take pictures of it and put it all up throughout their institutions and locker rooms and use it in recruiting.”

Bilas later went on “First Take” and offered his opinion on how this time-honored tradition should be eliminated.

“One time, all you have to do is once they’re on the court, don’t let them off,” Bilas said. “Just say, ‘You’re all detained’ and give them all citations or arrest them if you want to and then court stormings will stop the next day.”

All of this comes in response to Duke star Kyle Filipowski injuring his ankle in the midst of an upset loss to Wake Forest on the road which, expectedly, ended in a court storm.

Wake Forest takes down Duke

Kyle Filipowski got hurt in the court storm
pic.twitter.com/dDsv80mJ5d

— Pardon My Take (@PardonMyTake) February 24, 2024

This, along with players like Iowa women’s basketball phenom Caitlyn Clark running into an Ohio State fan after a road loss is dredging up the dialogue of eliminating court storming.

But how many athletes have ever been actually injured during a court storm? Zero. Filipowski was cleared to play in the Blue Devils’ next game against Louisville, and Clark was never in question of missing time post-collision.

“Give me a list of college basketball players severely injured from court storming in my life,” Colin Cowherd, host of the talk show “The Herd” said. “Men’s college basketball players, on average, are 6 foot 5 and 6′ foot 6, 6 ‘8, 7-footers. They bang around for two and a half hours, and that’s just in games, not mentioning practice. So they can’t handle bumping into Ethan, the theater major once a year?”

While Cowherd’s take on the situation invalidates the safety that college athletes are entitled to, it does raise the point that in the decades that court stormings have happened, no player has ever missed a game because of a court-storming incident.

Court-stormings also tend to be reserved for wins over teams that fans didn’t expect their school to beat or wins over heated rivals.

You have to be aware, as a coach, that these things happen. If you’re like Jon Scheyer, coach of a blue-blood school like Duke, you have to know if you get beat, especially on the road in an upset, the fans are going to flood the court. It takes 10 minutes to inform your players that “Hey, these are the exits, this is our tunnel. If we lose, get off the court as soon as possible.”

The competitive-minded people out there would call this “preparing to lose” but rather it’s “preparing for safety.” Not to say Filipowski was in the wrong, no one should have insult added to injury after an emotional loss, but as opposed to some of his teammates, he made no concerted effort to get off the court after fans began to rush.

Oftentimes, coaches of the home team, if ahead by a decent margin, will call a timeout so the opposing team can get their players off to avoid any risks. This mitigates any concern for player safety by doing so. Admittedly, this method only works in games where it is out of hand late. On buzzer beaters, there’s no way to quickly get players off the court in time.

The issue doesn’t lie in the court storm, it’s in player safety, but no winning player has ever complained about a court storm. At the end of the day, they’re students too, and everyone watching them play is a peer. Those players who celebrated with the fans on the court went to class with some of them the following Monday.

There is no right answer to this “problem.” Arresting hundreds of fans for storming a court is unrealistic (and dramatic), but player safety admittedly cannot be thrown to the wayside. The most obvious answer would be to wait until players have left the court, but that means holding back hundreds for about a minute or two, which could pose its own problems.

Either way, court storming is one of the most memorable and consistent traditions in college basketball, and it isn’t going anywhere. If you’re a court-storming fan, just watch where you’re going.

.

Court storming is a hazard, not a tradition – Luke White

Traditions are a prime example of what makes college sports so great, and in my opinion, gives them the upper hand over professional sports.

The passion and spirit of college athletics is unmatched, making them a completely different product than what you’ll find at the professional level. You won’t find the pinnacle of sports fandom in urban jungles like Los Angeles, Miami or Atlanta, but rather in college towns such as Baton Rouge, Louisiana, Tuscaloosa, Alabama and College Station.

Winston-Salem, North Carolina found itself in that discussion last weekend, when hometown Wake Forest upset No. 8 Duke in a men’s basketball game on Feb. 24. The win was one of the most significant in program history, and the Demon Deacon faithful acted accordingly with one of the sport’s most time-honored traditions: court storming.

The scene looked like when one steps in an ant mound, as students flooded the court to celebrate the euphoria of the game they witnessed. However, it wasn’t all joy and glee for the Blue Devils’ sophomore center Kyle Filipowski, whose ankle was injured while trying to escape the melee. The team’s staff formed a human wall around him as he was helped back to the locker room.

Filipowski isn’t the only athlete at the top of their sport to risk injury with opposing fans after a court storming this season. Iowa senior guard Caitlin Clark, now the all-time leading scorer in women’s basketball, collided with an Ohio State fan on the court on Jan. 21.

Storming isn’t just limited to basketball courts, but football fields as well. In 2022, a Texas player was shoved from behind by a senseless Texas Tech fan. In 2023, a video surfaced of a Kansas supporter directly taunting an Oklahoma player in his face.

These negative instances have given rise to a debate that I’ll let Duke coach Jon Scheyer explain.

“When are we going to ban court storming?” Scheyer posed. “It’s a dangerous thing.”

Court storming embodies college spirit, but it comes at a cost to those that actually belong on the court: players, coaches and staff. While it may be fun for the fans sprinting onto the playing area, it represents a hazard to those trying to get off of it.

These aren’t normal crowds we’re talking about, either. Imagine a court storming like Wake Forest’s, where, after witnessing an intense back-and-forth contest, fans flood the floor. They’re pumped full of adrenaline, and common sense may not take priority over the excitement of joining the crowd.

While rushing the court not only presents the risk of accidental harm to others, such as colliding or running into others, it allows those in the crowd to release aggression on opposing players and staff members. Regardless of the intent behind Filipowski’s injury, it could have been prevented by keeping fans where they belong: in their seats.

“I’ve already heard that there [are] some videos of [me] getting punched in the back, so I absolutely feel like it was personal, intentional for sure,” Filipwoski said. “There’s no reason why they see a big guy like me trying to work my way off the court and can’t work their way around me. There’s no excuse for that.”

So, how to go about preventing court storms? The simple solution seems to be an added security and law enforcement presence at high-profile games. I’ve seen it firsthand at Reed Arena, where a line of security formed around the perimeter of the court following wins over No. 2 Alabama in 2023 and No. 6 Kentucky this year.

The safety of those involved in the game ought to be paramount, and part of that is keeping opposing teams separated from fans. So, why not bring the home team to its fans, rather than vice versa? Give players the opportunity to celebrate in the student section with those that believed in them to pull out the win.

Only in college athletics are fans able to run on the playing surface postgame and not be put in handcuffs. Run on the court following a Warriors-Lakers NBA game and let me know how that works out for you.

Those rules are in place for a reason, and it’s to maintain the safety of the players. Fans are unpredictable, and when people are at risk, court storming is no longer a tradition, but a hazard.

Oh, and get off my lawn.

Donate to The Battalion

Your donation will support the student journalists of Texas A&M University - College Station. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

About the Contributors

Hunter Mitchell, Associate Sports Editor

Hunter Mitchell is a sport management senior minoring in journalism. Hunter has covered football, men's and women's basketball, baseball, volleyball, softball, hockey, cross country, track and field, along with swim and dive. Hunter's favorite sport is college basketball, and he is a member of the U.S. Basketball Writer's Association. Hunter also hosts weekly episodes of the Home Turf sports podcast.

Luke White, Sports Editor

Luke White is a senior telecommunication media studies major and sport management minor from Round Rock, Texas. He has served as head sports editor since May 2023.

Ishika Samant, Former Photo Chief

Ishika Samant served multiple roles at The Battalion as photo chief, managing editor, multimedia editor and social media editor through her tenure from 2021 to 2024.