The Student News Site of Texas A&M University - College Station

The Battalion

The Student News Site of Texas A&M University - College Station

The Battalion

The Student News Site of Texas A&M University - College Station

The Battalion

The intersection of Bizzell Street and College Avenue on Monday, Jan. 22, 2024.
Farmers fight Hurricane Beryl
Aggies across South Texas left reeling in wake of unexpectedly dangerous storm
J. M. Wise, News Reporter • July 20, 2024
Texas A&M LB Taurean York (21) speaks during the 2024 SEC Media Day at the Omni Hotel in Dallas, Texas on Thursday July 18, 2024. (Hannah Harrison/The Battalion)
A&M predicted to finish ninth in SEC football media poll, three Aggies earn preseason honors
Luke White, Sports Editor • July 19, 2024

Texas A&M football is expected to finish in the middle of the pack in the conference this season, per the SEC football preseason media poll...

Bob Rogers, holding a special edition of The Battalion.
Lyle Lovett, other past students remember Bob Rogers
Shalina SabihJuly 15, 2024

In his various positions, Professor Emeritus Bob Rogers laid down the stepping stones that student journalists at Texas A&M walk today, carving...

Chancellor John Sharp during a Board of Regents meeting discussing the appointmet of interim dean Mark Welsh and discussion of a McElroy settlement on Sunday, July 30, 2023 in the Memorial Student Center.
Analysis: Chancellor Sharp’s retirement comes with new dilemmas
Nicholas Gutteridge, Managing Editor • July 2, 2024

Texas A&M System Chancellor John Sharp announced Monday he will be retiring on June 30, 2025.  A figure notorious in state politics,...

Not all stars burn brightly

Photo by By Lawrence Smelser
Kevin Sumlin addressing the media on National Signing Day

The vaunted and highly sought after five-star recruit. Typically a player who was the superstar on his high school squad and was recruited by many different schools. The recruit is only 17 or 18 years old and has already met with the smartest minds in college football who try to persuade him to be on their team. The recruit has been dubbed a five-star athlete, but remains only a high school teenager. The youngster still has yet to play ball against college athletes who have proven themselves on a college level.

The recruit then joins the team, and if they enroll early, they play spring football. If they go as scheduled, they start practicing in the summer or fall with the team. The player will join up with other fellow recruits and walk-ons. Some were two stars, some were four stars, one or two will be five stars, and there will be “no stars.” The stars given to the players are just a number. What isn’t attributed to the player are qualities of hard work, determination and a good attitude. 

One perfect example is J.J. Watt of the Houston Texans, a two-time NFL Defensive Player of the Year and a four-time Pro Bowler. Watt nearly secured the MVP award but finished second behind Aaron Rodgers in 2014, which is a rarity for defensive players. Watt was a two-star athlete coming out of Pewaukee High School in Wisconsin and originally went to Central Michigan. Watt then transferred to Wisconsin and walked on to the football team. From then on, the 26-year-old gradually improved and is now a household name. 

Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver Antonio Brown is another prime example of a player reaching great heights despite not being highly rated. Brown received zero stars by recruiting site, but flourished at Central Michigan and was drafted low, during the sixth round as the 195th overall pick. In the NFL, Brown has already cemented his name in the history books. He has made the Pro Bowl four out of his six years in the league, and was also the AFC Offensive Player of the Year in 2014. He leads the league in receptions the last two seasons and is arguably the best wide receiver currently in the NFL. The 5-foot-10 receiver worked hard and showed determination to make it to the top and succeed.

No matter how many games a player won in high school, or how “famous” they are due to their five-star rating, it’s what they do on the field that will determine their success at the next level. Five-star quarterback Mitch Mustain never found success in college. Mustain was named the High School Player of the Year by PARADE in 2006, 2005-2006 Gatorade National Player of the Year, and the 2005 USA Today National Player of the Year. 

Mustain played under current Auburn head coach Gus Malzahn in high school and was considered a prodigy. However, the young quarterback’s career never panned out after playing at Arkansas briefly and starting only eight games, he transferred to USC but sat behind Matt Barkley and Mark Sanchez for most of his career. Mustain never eclipsed 1,000 yards passing with either program and finished his college career with 13 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. 

At Texas A&M, two five-star quarterbacks Kyle Allen and Kyler Murray, came to A&M extremely decorated out of high school, but neither showcased a highly impressive body of work and both transferred during the 2015 season before the Music City Bowl. Allen performed better than Murray going 9-5 as a starter, but eventually found himself benched after poor performances against Alabama and Ole Miss.

Murray was ranked the No. 1 dual-threat quarterback coming out of high school and won the Gatorade Player of the Year award after leading Allen High School to a 42-0 record over three seasons and winning three state championships. 

What ensued for Murray at Texas A&M was a culmination of hype, a negative attitude, and constant competition for the quarterback position. The Allen native finished with a 2-1 record but was constantly surrounded by a number of issues. After Murray entered A&M’s game against Alabama, the freshman threw an interception and was taken out of the game. Murray “cussed” out offensive coordinator Jake Spavital on the sidelines after being withdrawn and eventually transferred to Oklahoma. 

Stars give a good indication of talent out of high school, but they don’t prove a player’s worth or success at the collegiate or professional level. Determination, hard work and attitude do. After all, seven of the last ten Heisman winners were not given five stars coming out of high school. Three winners were three-star recruits — Marcus Mariota, Johnny Manziel and Sam Bradford. 


Lawrence Smelser is a journalism junior and co-sports editor for The Battalion.

Leave a Comment
Donate to The Battalion

Your donation will support the student journalists of Texas A&M University - College Station. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
Donate to The Battalion

Comments (0)

All The Battalion Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *