For almost a decade, Texas A&M students with disabilities have allegedly been harassed and verbally abused when attempting to participate in on-campus traditions.
Four Aggies discussed their experiences and difficulties with gaining access to stadiums and regular campus facilities, ranging from lack of wheelchair access to harassment from fans in Kyle Field.
Structural engineering graduate Brianna Vogel, president of Aggies with Disabilities and an ambulatory wheelchair user, said she has faced difficulties participating in Aggie traditions for seven years.
“I went to Yell Practice once freshman year … and it was such a negative experience that I said, ‘I don’t want to go to Yell Practice again,’” Vogel said. “All I could see was rear ends. And my mom had gone with me, and she was frustrated … she’s deaf and she couldn’t see the ASL interpreter.”
Vogel has postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, or POTS, which is caused by blood vessels improperly circulating blood, leading to lightheadedness when standing. For Vogel — and the approximately 3,000 students with disabilities at A&M — Kyle Field has dedicated ADA sections in which standing is not permitted, allowing students in wheelchairs to see the field.
For people with POTS, being forced to stand up during games may present a physical hazard to their health, Vogel said.
“They sit down, and they start getting yelled at,” Vogel said. “They start getting booed … There’s at least one occasion where a student stood back up just to get people to be quiet, and she immediately passed out and got a concussion.”
Forensic and investigative sciences sophomore Samantha Sapp is only the fourth wheelchair user to be in the Corps of Cadets, a position which she says has made her aware of the inaccessibility of many of A&M’s traditions.
At the McNeese game on Sept. 7, Sapp and another Corps member who uses a wheelchair had security called on them after they asked a student in front of them to sit during kickoff so they could see the field.
Sapp said her experiences with football games have been so exhausting that she avoids going to sporting events that she is not required to attend. During most games, Sapp cannot see the field due to students standing in front of her.
“Guess what they did the entirety of the game?” Sapp said. “They stood in the no-standing seats … Security came over, corrected them … and the students then cussed out security. I was honestly scared to confront any of them about it because they cursed out a security guard. What are they going to do to me?”
Sapp has been advised to never be alone at Kyle Field by other students in the Corps with disabilities who have been verbally and physically attacked.
“It’s almost like the moment that you walk in, everyone is like, ‘Oh, you can’t do our tradition?” Sapp said. “Then you don’t deserve to be an Aggie.’ And that’s very, very disheartening.”
Kyle Field is not the only place on campus with physical barriers for students with disabilities. Placing pennies on Sully’s feet, visiting the Bonfire Memorial and even moving through Aggie Park are all challenging for students who use wheelchairs or other adaptive equipment.
“Aggie Park is the newest area on campus … and I would argue it’s the worst place on campus for a wheelchair,” Sapp said. “I had to leave my wheelchair outside of the bathroom to get inside. If you’re not an ambulatory wheelchair user, you have to crawl across the bathroom floor.”
Agricultural leadership graduate student Ty Sutton, one of the first students in the Corps to use a wheelchair, said he has consistently encountered structural and physical barriers that prevent him from accessing educational facilities or experiencing campus life.
“The worst experience I had was during the Auburn game in 2023,” Sutton said. “Most of these people were drunk. It’s all chaos. It’s like talking to a brick wall … and we asked them to sit down because we couldn’t see, and they said ‘No, we stand for the 12th Man. We’re not sitting.’”
When Sutton tried to find a security guard, there were none available for his section. When he returned to his section, the behavior continued to escalate.
“One of the guys turns around and gives me his middle finger and says, ‘If you can’t effing stand, you shouldn’t effing be here,’” Sutton said.
Sutton said he tried to obtain a ticket outside of ADA seating and was allegedly denied due to his disability. Under the ADA, public facilities have to provide equal access to seats for patrons with disabilities. Refusing to allow students with disabilities to sit outside of ADA seating is not allowed under the federal law.
According to A&M’s website on ADA compliance, all reports of civil rights violations are forwarded to the Office of Civil Rights and Equities, or CREI, which has been historically underfunded and understaffed. Best Crowd Management, the contractor who trains security guards for Kyle Field, denied to interview.
Educational administration and human resource development graduate Danielle Koehler has been experiencing difficulties at Kyle Field since she enrolled in 2019. Both her and her husband — a veteran with 100% disability — require accessible seating.
“When I talk to the 12th Man, they say, ‘Oh, it’s on security to fix the problem,’” Koehler said. “But you hire them. You do the contract. It is your problem, and the students should be your number one priority — and the ADA section should be a priority.”
Koehler and her husband were seated in the ADA section during the Aug. 31 football game against Notre Dame when she realized that people standing next to her had tickets for a different section. When security guards came to check tickets, the situation only escalated.
“They started arguing with security, saying, ‘Well, somebody is in my seat, so I came here because nobody is sitting here,’” Koehler said.
The people then left with security and returned. Koehler’s previous attempts at changing how ADA seats are treated within Kyle Field resulted in the installment of a metal sign in sections that are designated as ‘No Standing.’
Erin Jones, the executive associate athletic director over game management and special events, said it’s difficult to ensure patron safety when students fail to comply with security guards’ instructions. While guards can remove patrons from the stadium, she said it is often the last resort.
“We have been told in many cases, by students, that when the ushers go through there to tell them to sit down, they cuss them out, they yell at them, they tell them to mind their own business,” Jones said.
For students who have complaints about conduct, Jones recommended speaking up. Ticket holders need to follow rules in their section, and ADA section tickets state that standing is not allowed.
“It would be a great learning experience for the student body, policing themselves,” Jones said.
For students with disabilities like Vogel, discrimination at Kyle Field is where they draw the line.
“We already deal with isolation and segregation and discrimination everywhere else,” Vogel said. “We just want to be able to participate.”
Lisa Cotropia '79 • Oct 7, 2024 at 7:15 am
After reading this article, I experienced a multitude of reactions including shame, anger, and sadness. I can’t believe that Aggies would treat their fellow students in this manner. What happened to the fellowship that used to be shared across the campus? I wish I could talk directly with those students who have harassed others because of their disabilities. If they only realized that they are a car accident away from being unable to stand or suffer other debilitating conditions. I almost feel sorry for them because one day they will be the recipients of demeaning treatment. What goes around comes around. What is Chancellor Sharp doing about this horrific behavior? Does he even care?
Angie • Sep 29, 2024 at 9:10 pm
Erin Jones is a disgrace. “A learning experience” for people just trying to watch a football game to have do the policing as well, when the offenders already don’t respect the ushers?! That woman’s out of her mind. If people relied on doing that, it’s not going to end well for the very people being harassed and bullied.
Joe Hallmark '73 • Sep 28, 2024 at 8:41 pm
It starts at the top.
I gave up my football season tickets when people with disabilities were bashed by a VP of the 12th Man Foundation. A security person contacted the VP on gameday with a problem I was having, and the VP, not knowing I could hear the radio, started a tirade about how much trouble “those crippled people” cause.
As an aside, various construction people and the 12th Man representatives all admitted the reason the entire east side of Kyle Field was not replaced when the stadium was upgraded was to avoid the ADA accommodations.
Missy Norrell ‘90 • Sep 28, 2024 at 9:44 am
I am a Former Student Class of ‘90. My husband is an Old Ag. My daughter is an Old Ag. My son-in-law is an Old Ag. What I read in this article frankly makes me angry. Texas A&M has a reputation for being the friendliest university when it comes to tailgating, hosting opposing fans and all the rest. So why should this be any different at all for one of our own who needs an accommodation? Now that I am personally in a wheelchair, I get every single thing that these Aggies are saying. I’ve now been the one left out due to a disability. There are places I can’t go due to lack of accessibility. There are people who make the rudest comments because of the chair. If an Ag cusses someone out at a football game (an Ag with a disability, a staffer, whoever) they should be shown the door. There is no place for that in Kyle Field or anywhere else on campus. If the offending Ag has a sports pass, they should lose it. That’s a privilege, not a right.
When I return to campus, I’ll have to do some of our traditions differently now. I would hate to think that the university that I love and have supported as best I can through donations would let something like the descriptions in this article happen to me. There is no excuse.
We are the Aggies, the Aggies are we. True to each other as Aggies can be.
Robin • Sep 27, 2024 at 11:46 am
I work here and reading this article disgusted me. A BILLION dollar university and this is what you do to your students that pay massive amounts of money to attend and are treated with disrespect and denied at least a minimum amount of courtesy and accessibility. The chancellor needs to step up and pay attention to all students not just walking,hearing,and seeing ones.
Jen Dulin • Sep 26, 2024 at 12:20 pm
As a former student and current TAMU Biology Professor with a lab that studies spinal cord injury research, and as an advocate for people living with disabilities, I’m disgusted that some of our Aggies would act this way. Shaming people for being unable to stand?! I hope you never know how life-altering it can be to live with a disability. Do better.
Jo Raye Lands • Sep 26, 2024 at 6:54 pm